Measuring the return on investment (ROI) of offshoring and diversity strategies is crucial for businesses as it helps assess these initiatives’ financial benefits and effectiveness, provides insights into their long-term impact on business performance, enables data-driven decisions, optimizes resource allocation, and demonstrates their value to stakeholders.
In this article, we’ll provide an overview of offshoring and diversity management, provide ways to determine the ROI of offshoring and diversity, and analyze the long-term impact of offshoring and diversity.
Offshoring Overview
Offshoring is the practice of relocating business operations to another country, either through setting up a branch or unit of the business or by contracting with a third-party vendor.
Offshoring can include manufacturing, customer support, software development, and other business processes that are relocated to countries like India, China, the Philippines, and Eastern Europe.
It allows companies to benefit from lower labor costs in developing countries, access highly qualified professionals at affordable rates, and focus on core operations, ultimately leading to business growth.
Diversity Management Overview
Diversity management refers to an organization’s intentional efforts to plan and implement changes in its systems and practices to effectively manage people from diverse backgrounds.
Diversity management involves building and managing a diverse team to create a more inclusive workplace environment.
Significance within Organizations:
- Enhanced Performance: Companies with diverse executive teams have shown better performance than those lacking gender and ethnic diversity.
- Employee Engagement: Diversity management can lead to a more engaged workforce, improving overall employee experience, productivity, retention, job satisfaction, recruitment, and hiring.
- Financial Returns: Research indicates a correlation between financial returns and management teams with diverse representation.
Types of Diversity and Strategic Leveraging:
- Intranational Diversity Management: Managing a workforce within a single national entity by recruiting from diverse audiences and highlighting diversity initiatives during recruitment.
- Cross-National Diversity Management: Managing a workforce with citizens from different countries requires considering laws in various locations.
Common Misconceptions:
- Solely Numeric Evaluation: Relying solely on diversity numbers as a metric for success is a common mistake. Engagement, sense of belonging, and diverse leadership are also crucial indicators of success in diversity efforts.
- Diverse Leadership Importance: Having diverse leaders is essential for fostering an inclusive workplace, as they possess the necessary skills to drive diversity and inclusion initiatives effectively.
Diversity management is vital for creating inclusive workplaces that foster innovation, employee engagement, and organizational success. Organizations can build stronger, more resilient teams that drive performance and growth by strategically leveraging different types of diversity and dispelling common misconceptions.
Evaluating Offshoring ROI
When evaluating the return on investment (ROI) of offshoring, several key metrics are commonly used to assess the impact of this strategy. These metrics include:
- Cost Savings: Calculate the difference in labor costs between offshore and onshore resources, considering factors like salaries, benefits, training, and overhead expenses.
- Scale of Work: Determine if offshoring has enabled handling increased workloads, peak periods, or expansion into new markets more effectively.
- Quality Improvements: Assess the quality of work delivered offshore compared to onshore standards through client, stakeholder, and internal team feedback.
- Productivity Gains: Measure operational expertise, agent adaptability, increased productivity, and response rates.
- Service Quality: Evaluate overall customer/user satisfaction, accuracy, reliability, availability, and security of tasks and documentation.
- Operating Efficiency: Monitor throughput time and other process performance metrics to identify gaps and areas of improvement.
Here are two examples of how these metrics can be applied:
An accounting firm offshores its recruitment process to a specialized agency to reduce costs while maintaining or improving candidate quality. Metrics include agency fees, training costs, time to fill positions, and quality of hires.
A company leverages offshore software development to enhance productivity and reduce operational costs. Metrics focus on cost savings, efficiency gains, and revenue improvement.
When calculating offshoring ROI, you may overlook some factors or encounter some pitfalls, such as:
Hidden Costs: Consider additional expenses like personnel training, governance systems, and management time that may not be immediately apparent but impact return on investment significantly.
Overestimation: Be cautious of overestimating cost savings or underestimating hidden costs, which can lead to unrealistic ROI expectations.
Revenue Impact: While cost savings are important, revenue improvement often significantly affects the overall return on investment from offshoring initiatives.
By carefully tracking these metrics and considering potential pitfalls when calculating offshoring ROI, organizations can make informed decisions regarding their offshoring strategies and maximize the benefits of such initiatives.
Evaluating Diversity Strategy ROI
Companies prioritizing diversity and inclusion initiatives can reap significant benefits, including increased revenue growth, improved employee retention rates, and higher customer satisfaction.
The impact of diversity strategies extends far beyond mere numbers. While quantitative measures like revenue growth and cost savings are crucial indicators of success, the qualitative aspects of diversity initiatives play an equally vital role.
Quantitative Measures: Effective diversity strategies can lead to revenue growth, increased productivity, and cost savings.
Qualitative Indicators: Improved team collaboration, innovation, and organizational culture are outcomes of successful diversity initiatives.
Here are some case studies demonstrating the positive impacts of effective diversity strategies:
Indeed’s DEI Training Case Study
Indeed implemented diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) training that led to increased engagement, happiness, and productivity, resulting in revenue growth and cost savings.
The training program showed a final ROI of 699%, with an increase in productivity per participant of 30% attributable to the training.
SSA Group’s DEI Initiatives
SSA Group focused on increasing diverse vendors, expanding recruitment efforts, and providing mentorship programs to support diverse talent advancement.
Their initiatives led to higher retention for diverse employees, saving over $6000 per new hire and fostering a sustained commitment to operationalizing DEI.
HR Analytics for Diversity Inclusion ROI
A technology organization improved employee engagement and reduced turnover by implementing an Executive & Operational Diversity Council and diversity inclusion interventions based on data analytics.
The organization witnessed a 22% increase in employee engagement scores and a significant decrease in minority group attrition.
These case studies highlight the tangible benefits of implementing robust diversity strategies that go beyond compliance to drive innovation, decision-making, and overall financial performance.
Long-Term Impact Analysis
Offshoring and diversity strategies can have both positive and negative long-term effects on business performance.
Offshoring can lead to cost savings, access to a global talent pool, and exploration of new markets. Offshoring can also increase cultural diversity, ultimately fostering innovation and adaptability.
Diversity strategies can lead to a more diverse workforce, bringing fresh ideas and new ways of approaching business challenges.
However, offshoring and diversity can lead to challenges related to communication, cultural differences, and potential conflicts. And these can be perceived as a risks. Thus effective management of offshore operations requires addressing these challenges.
How to Overcome Challenges
Businesses can take several steps to mitigate negative consequences while maximizing positive outcomes.
For offshoring, companies must evaluate which processes or operations are suitable for relocation and identify the best offshore locations.
Factors influencing this decision include costs, availability of skilled workforce, political stability, infrastructure, and the legal and regulatory environment.
Companies must also assess whether the benefits of offshoring outweigh the potential risks and challenges.
For diversity strategies, companies can provide diversity training to employees, establish clear communication channels, and create a culture of inclusion.
Why Partner with iSupport Worldwide
iSupport Worldwide offers offshore teams from the Philippines, leveraging its rich cultural and English-speaking population for quick access to a diverse talent pool. Thus mitigating the risk of cultural and language barriers.
iSupport Worldwide is a three-time awardee of the Inc. 5000—recognized for its dedication to delivering high-quality services and providing exceptional support to clients globally through diversity, equity, and inclusion.
For example, a major distributor of imprintable apparel and accessories in the United States selected iSupport Worldwide as a dependable partner due to our competitive pricing and efficient recruitment process.
The offshore team, composed of diverse individuals, played a pivotal role in driving business expansion through its adherence to the strict deadline for customer order processing—providing client operation savings of 78% to 138%.
Are you ready to diversify your workforce and increase your return on investment?
Fill out the form, and we’ll contact you for a free, no-obligation assessment of your hiring needs.